Choosing the right real estate agent isn’t just about finding someone licensed—it’s about finding someone who can protect your money, negotiate strategically, and guide you through one of the biggest financial decisions you’ll ever make.

Whether you’re buying or selling, the agent you hire directly impacts your price, timeline, stress level, and overall experience.

Here’s how to make sure you choose the best one for your needs—not just the most visible one online.


1. Look for Local Market Expertise

Real estate is hyper-local.

You don’t want an agent who “works everywhere.” You want one who knows:

  • Your neighborhood pricing trends
  • School district demand
  • Buyer demographics
  • Local inventory patterns
  • Off-market opportunities

Ask:

  • How many homes have you sold in this area?
  • What’s the average days on market?
  • What price range do you specialize in?

Local knowledge drives pricing accuracy and negotiation strength.


2. Review Their Track Record

Experience matters—but relevance matters more.

Look at:

  • Recent closings (last 12 months)
  • List price vs. sale price ratios
  • Days on market averages
  • Price point specialization

An agent who sells frequently in your price range understands the buyer pool you’re targeting.


3. Evaluate Their Marketing Strategy (For Sellers)

If you’re selling, marketing is everything.

Strong agents offer more than just MLS exposure.

Ask what’s included:

  • Professional photography
  • Video walkthroughs
  • Social media ads
  • Email marketing
  • Open houses
  • Agent network promotion

The difference between basic and strategic marketing can mean thousands in your final price.


4. Ask About Their Negotiation Approach

Every agent can submit an offer—not every agent can negotiate effectively.

Ask scenarios like:

  • How do you handle multiple offers?
  • How do you negotiate inspection repairs?
  • What strategies do you use in a competitive market?

You’re hiring someone to advocate for your money—not just facilitate paperwork.


5. Communication Style & Availability

This is where many deals succeed—or fall apart.

You want an agent who is:

  • Responsive
  • Proactive
  • Clear in communication
  • Available during key decision windows

Ask:

  • What’s your average response time?
  • Do you work solo or with a team?
  • Who handles showings and negotiations?

Real estate moves fast. Delayed communication can cost opportunities.


6. Check Reviews & Testimonials

Online reviews give insight into real client experiences.

Look for patterns in feedback:

  • Negotiation strength
  • Communication quality
  • Problem-solving ability
  • Contract knowledge

One or two bad reviews happen. Consistent negative themes are red flags.


7. Understand Their Network

Top agents bring more than themselves—they bring an ecosystem.

This includes:

  • Lenders
  • Inspectors
  • Contractors
  • Title companies
  • Attorneys (if needed)

A strong network makes transactions smoother and faster.


8. Make Sure They Educate—Not Pressure

The best agents guide you. They don’t rush you.

You should feel:

  • Informed
  • Empowered
  • Strategically advised
  • Not pushed into decisions

If an agent is more focused on closing than counseling, keep looking.


9. Compare Commission & Value (For Sellers)

Commission matters—but value matters more.

A lower commission doesn’t always mean higher profit if:

  • Marketing is weak
  • Pricing is off
  • Negotiation is poor

Focus on net proceeds—not just listing fees.


10. Trust Your Gut

Data matters. But so does comfort.

Ask yourself:

  • Do I trust their advice?
  • Do they listen to my goals?
  • Do I feel represented—or sold to?

You’ll be working closely together—alignment matters.


Red Flags to Watch For

🚩 Overpromising price just to win your listing
🚩 Poor communication early on
🚩 Limited local sales history
🚩 Weak marketing presentation
🚩 Pressure to sign quickly

If you see these upfront, expect challenges later.


Quick Interview Questions to Ask

When vetting agents, use this checklist:

  • How many homes did you sell last year?
  • What’s your strategy for my price range?
  • How will you market my home?
  • How do you handle bidding wars?
  • What happens if issues come up during inspections?

Their answers will tell you everything about their skill level.


Final Thoughts

The “best” real estate agent isn’t the one with the most billboards—it’s the one with the right mix of:

  • Local expertise
  • Negotiation skill
  • Marketing strategy
  • Communication
  • Integrity

Choosing wisely can mean:

  • More money in your pocket
  • Less stress during the process
  • A smoother closing experience

Take your time, interview a few, and hire the one who treats your goals like their own.

Leave a comment

Quote of the week

"People ask me what I do in the winter when there's no baseball. I'll tell you what I do. I stare out the window and wait for spring."

~ Rogers Hornsby